Carbon Offsets vs Carbon Removal: What's the Difference?

Offsets can avoid or remove emissions; carbon removal pulls CO2 from the air. Learn the difference, the integrity debate and how to judge credits.

By
Published:
Oct 25, 2026
Updated:
Oct 30, 2026

People often use "carbon offsets" and "carbon removal" as if they mean the same thing. They do not. The difference affects how credible a company's climate claims are, and how much it costs to back them up.

At a glance

  • Carbon offset: a credit representing one tonne of CO₂ that was avoided, reduced or removed somewhere else.
  • Carbon removal: taking CO₂ out of the atmosphere and storing it.
  • The key point: all removals can be sold as credits, but not all offset credits are removals.
  • Direction of travel: guidance such as the Oxford Principles pushes buyers toward durable removals over time.
  • Price gap: BCG cited an average of $3 to $6 per tonne in the voluntary offset market in 2020, against a projected $35 to $80 per tonne for its own blend including removals.
  • Last updated: October 2026.

What is a carbon offset?

A carbon offset is a credit a company buys to compensate for emissions it has not eliminated. One credit represents one tonne of CO₂ equivalent. The credit can come from different kinds of projects.

Avoidance and reduction vs removal

Offset projects fall into two broad groups:

  • Avoidance or reduction credits pay for emissions that would otherwise have happened, for example protecting a forest that was at risk of being cut down, or replacing a polluting cooking stove.
  • Removal credits pay for CO₂ that is actively pulled out of the air and stored, for example through direct air capture, biochar, enhanced rock weathering or nature-based solutions.

Avoidance helps stop emissions from rising. Removal lowers the amount of CO₂ already in the air. Net zero needs both, along with deep cuts to a company's own emissions.

Why offsets have been criticised

Avoidance credits, especially from forest protection, have faced scrutiny over whether they represent real climate benefit. In January 2023 a Guardian investigation alleged that more than 90% of Verra's rainforest offset credits were likely "phantom credits". Verra disputed the findings and said it was moving forest projects to an updated methodology. Separately, the rating firm Calyx Global estimated that almost two-thirds of forest offset projects had a high risk of overestimated baselines. The core problem is the baseline: if a project overstates how much forest would have been lost, it sells credits for emissions that were never going to happen.

Removal credits face their own tests, such as whether the carbon stays stored and whether the amount is measured accurately. See our carbon removal credits guide for how quality is assessed.

What are the Oxford Principles?

The Oxford Principles for Net Zero Aligned Carbon Offsetting, revised in 2024, set out how organisations should use offsets. In plain terms:

  1. Cut emissions first. Reduce your own emissions, use only credits that are measurable, verified and additional, and be transparent.
  2. Shift to carbon removal. Move over time from avoidance credits to credits for removing CO₂, aiming for all residual emissions to be offset by removals by 2050 at the latest.
  3. Shift to long-lived storage. Removed carbon should stay out of the atmosphere for centuries or longer, for example through geological storage or mineralization. Some nature-based projects can help in the short to medium term while durable methods scale up.
  4. Support the market for removals. Long-term, investable agreements help new technologies scale.

Quality labels and standards

The Integrity Council for the Voluntary Carbon Market (ICVCM) sets a benchmark called the Core Carbon Principles (CCP). Credits from methodologies that meet it can carry a CCP label. In October 2025 the Council approved a batch of six engineered carbon dioxide removal methodologies as fit to carry the label, including ones from Gold Standard and Isometric. A label is a useful signal, but buyers still need to check the specific project.

What each option costs

Removal costs more than most offsets. In 2020 BCG cited a voluntary offset market average of $3 to $6 per tonne, and projected that its own blend of credits would cost about $35 per tonne in 2025 and $80 per tonne in 2030 as it bought more removals. At the high end, Swiss Re described Climeworks' direct air capture prices as several hundred dollars per tonne in 2021. A June 2026 LSE Grantham Institute report says durable removal credit prices remain several times higher than carbon prices in the UK and EU emissions trading systems.

The delivery gap

Much contracted removal has not yet been delivered. The same LSE report found only 1.2% of contracted durable carbon removal had been delivered by the end of 2025, out of 43 million tonnes it analysed. When a company says it has "bought" removals, it is worth checking how much has actually been delivered.

How companies are shifting

BCG says it is moving from avoidance credits to removal credits, with removal at 52% of its portfolio in 2023 and a target of 100% by 2030. Swiss Re plans to raise the share of removal certificates it buys to 100% by 2030. UBS plans to neutralise the residual emissions from its operations in 2035 with carbon removal credits after cutting emissions by at least 90%. Large buyers such as Microsoft, Google and Stripe have contracted durable removal in advance. See the full overview of carbon dioxide removal.

How to judge a credit

  • Is it removal or avoidance? The label matters for net-zero claims.
  • How long does the carbon stay stored? Rock and mineral storage lasts far longer than a tree that could burn.
  • Is it additional? Would the project have happened without the credit income?
  • Is it measured and verified by a third party? Look for an independent standard.
  • Has it been delivered? A contract is not the same as a tonne removed.

FAQ

Is a carbon offset the same as carbon removal?

No. An offset is a credit that can represent avoided, reduced or removed emissions. Carbon removal specifically takes CO₂ out of the atmosphere.

Which is better, offsets or removal?

Removal does something avoidance cannot: it reduces the CO₂ already in the air. The Oxford Principles say buyers should shift toward removals over time, after cutting their own emissions first.

Can offsets replace cutting emissions?

No. Under the Oxford Principles, cutting your own emissions comes first, and credits are for what remains.

Why is carbon removal more expensive than offsets?

Durable removal methods such as direct air capture are still early and costly to build, while many avoidance credits are cheap. BCG cited $3 to $6 per tonne for the voluntary offset market average in 2020, compared with several hundred dollars per tonne for early direct air capture.

Sources

Act now

Reach out and join us in fighting climate change

Take the first step toward offsetting your unavoidable carbon emissions.

Remove CO2 with us